Short answer
Plastic is the value choice at $8.99 or less and reads cleanly in full color. Metal-faced premium badges ($12.49) and solid metal executive badges ($15.85) look more formal and hold up better to scratches and drops.
| Line | From | Look | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plastic | $8.99 | Clean, full color | Retail, food service, schools |
| Premium metal-faced | $12.49 | Brushed gold or silver face | Offices, dental, real estate |
| Executive solid metal | $15.85 | Heavier, formal | Banks, executives, hotels |